9 Most Valuable Jefferson Coins Worth Up to $3,450 – Check Your Change!

Among the many coins issued by the U.S. Mint, Jefferson Nickels stand out for both collectors and enthusiasts. Their long history, rare errors, and limited mintages have made them a favorite among numismatists. From wartime silver nickels to unique mint mark mistakes, these coins can be worth much more than face value.

Take a closer look at your change—you might discover a valuable gem hiding in plain sight. Let’s explore the nine most valuable Jefferson Nickels that could be worth money!

1. 1942-D “D Over D” Jefferson Nickel

This coin features a mint mark error where a “D” was punched over another “D.” Known as a repunched mint mark (RPM), this Denver-issued coin is one of the rarest varieties in the series. In circulated condition, it can fetch hundreds of dollars. Uncirculated versions are highly prized and often command several thousand dollars.

2. 1943-P Doubled Eye Jefferson Nickel

The 1943-P nickel has a distinctive error—doubling in Jefferson’s eye on the obverse. This is a Class III doubled die variety, making it a favorite among collectors. The value depends largely on its grade, with higher-grade examples selling for a premium.

3. 1997-P Jefferson Nickel (Special Strike, MS66)

This modern rarity was included in the 1997 Botanic Garden Mint Set, which had a limited mintage of just 25,000 sets. The coin features a satin finish and was struck with extra care. With such a low mintage and exceptional quality, these coins are highly collectible and command strong prices in MS66 or better.

4. 1939-D Jefferson Nickel

The 1939-D had the lowest mintage of any regular-issue Jefferson Nickel, with just over 3.5 million made. The low production was likely influenced by the lingering effects of the Great Depression and the looming World War II. High-grade specimens are especially valuable.

5. 1949-D “D Over S” Jefferson Nickel

This mint error features a “D” mint mark stamped over an “S,” creating a noticeable and collectible mistake. It likely resulted from using leftover dies that were already marked with an “S.” This type of error is highly desirable among collectors.

6. 1939-P Double Monticello Jefferson Nickel

This dramatic doubled die variety is most evident in the words “FIVE CENTS” and “MONTICELLO” on the reverse. The doubling shifts southeast, making it easily recognizable. Fewer than 1,000 examples are known, and most are in lower circulated grades.

7. 1955-D “D Over S” Jefferson Nickel

The 1955-D coin also displays a “D” mint mark punched over an “S,” creating a highly collectible RPM error. Any grade of this variety is scarce, and uncirculated versions are even harder to find. This coin is a must-have for serious collectors.

8. 1943-P “3 Over 2” Jefferson Nickel

This overdate variety shows a “3” struck over a “2” in the date, the only known overdate in the entire series. First identified in the 1940s, it wasn’t confirmed until 1977. Circulated examples are fairly accessible, while uncirculated coins are much rarer and more valuable.

9. 1954-S “S Over D” Jefferson Nickel

This mint mark error has an “S” struck over a faint “D.” While not as common as other varieties, it has fetched impressive auction results—one sold for $3,450 in 2004. It’s a standout coin from the San Francisco Mint.

Start Your Jefferson Nickel Collection Today

Whether you’re after historical pieces or rare mint errors, Jefferson Nickels offer incredible value to both new and experienced collectors. With the right eye, you might just find one of these valuable nickels in your pocket change.

FAQs